A planning inspector granted permission in principle on appeal for up to 9 homes at Willow Garth, Station Road, Howden, on 27 October 2026, after East Riding of Yorkshire Council refused the application. The site was found suitable in location, land use and amount of development, but homes still need technical details consent.
Got a site with planning potential? Book a call.
In a decision dated 27 October 2026, the inspector allowed the appeal for the paddock site (council reference 26/00473/PIP).
Why the council said no. Both sides agreed the site lies outside Howden's development limits, so it counts as countryside under Policy S4 of the East Riding Local Plan, which supports new homes there only in limited cases such as affordable or rural workers' housing. The council also argued the paddock acted as a buffer between a large housing allocation and open countryside.
Why the inspector disagreed. Land to the east is allocated in the local plan for around 1,865 new homes, and the inspector noted that work on the Howden relief road linked to that allocation has started. Once the allocation is built, the inspector found, the site would be surrounded by development on three sides and more closely tied to the town than to the countryside, with a planned neighbourhood centre within reach without a car. The inspector also found the site amounted to limited infilling within a group of houses, and concluded these material considerations outweighed the conflict with the development plan, even though the council can show a five-year housing land supply.
How permission in principle works. Government planning guidance describes permission in principle as a two-stage route for housing-led schemes. The first stage settles only location, land use and the amount of development. Everything else, such as layout, design and access, is assessed at the second stage, called technical details consent. No planning conditions can be attached to a permission in principle. Where it is granted by application, it lasts 3 years by default, and councils have a statutory 5 weeks to decide a valid application.
What it means for landowners. Permission in principle can be a lower-cost way to test whether a small site is acceptable before paying for full drawings and surveys. The Howden decision is also a reminder that a site outside settlement limits is not automatically a refusal: what is planned next door, and how the site will relate to it, carried real weight in this case. It is still only the first step, and the homes cannot be built until technical details consent is granted.
This note is general information only, not legal or compliance advice. Jonathan offers consultancy on gaming and casino licensing, site finding, site planning, planning applications and property feasibility. For introductions, contact Jules at pa@jonathantruelove.com.
Sources: Appeal decision 6013753, Land at Willow Garth, Howden (27 October 2026), via AppealBase; GOV.UK, Permission in principle (planning practice guidance)