North Yorkshire Council's Thirsk and Malton area planning committee has backed outline planning permission for up to 202 homes on two greenfield sites in the former Ryedale district: up to 150 homes on land south of Firthland Road in Pickering, put forward by Persimmon Homes, and up to 52 homes on land next to The Pastures in Sherburn, near Malton. Both applications were on the committee's agenda for its meeting on 22 October 2026.
Both sites sit outside the development limits in the Ryedale local plan, where new housing would not normally be supported. The council's planning officer report for Pickering says the council cannot show a five-year housing land supply for the Ryedale plan area (1.39 years), which brings national policy on unmet housing need into play. Officers concluded that the benefits of each scheme were not outweighed by the harm and recommended approval subject to conditions and a Section 106 legal agreement. Both schemes include 35 per cent affordable housing, with public open space and a children's play area.
Neither decision was straightforward. In Pickering, Yorkshire Water and the town council objected because the sewer network and treatment works do not have capacity, so officers proposed a condition preventing any home being occupied until sufficient sewerage capacity has been confirmed. In Sherburn, the local NHS integrated care board warned that the nearby GP practice does not have capacity and asked for a developer contribution of £61,368, and of 53 representations, 40 objected. The Local Democracy Reporting Service reports that the committee chair, Councillor Caroline Goodrick, said it was difficult to refuse applications like this without a five-year land supply.
What outline planning permission means. Government planning guidance describes an outline application as a decision on the general principles of how a site can be developed. Details of access, appearance, landscaping, layout and scale can be "reserved" for later approval. In both of these cases only the point of access into the site was decided now, so the house types, layout and design will come back to the council as reserved matters applications. Under section 92 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, reserved matters must normally be applied for within three years of the outline permission, and conditions or a Section 106 agreement can still shape what is finally built and when homes can be occupied.
For landowners and smaller developers, the practical lesson is that the local housing land supply position, infrastructure capacity such as drainage and GP places, and the detail of the conditions can matter as much as the site itself, so they are worth checking before any application is prepared.
This note is general information only, not legal or compliance advice. Jonathan offers consultancy on gaming and casino licensing, site finding, site planning, planning applications and property feasibility. For introductions, contact Jules at pa@jonathantruelove.com.
Need help with a licence, site or planning application? Get in touch.
Sources: North Yorkshire Council, officer report ZE25/00612/MOUT, 22 October 2026; TheBusinessDesk.com, 23 October 2026; Yorkshire Post (Local Democracy Reporting Service), 25 October 2026; GOV.UK, Making an application (planning practice guidance)